Meet the Creature Crew: Deer Creek’s Most Imaginative Cheeses

Deer Creek’s Animal Series Keeps Evolving, One Creature and Flavor Twist at a Time

Wisconsin has plenty of great Cheddar, but Deer Creek Cheese didn’t want “plenty”—they wanted extraordinary. Enter the Animal Series: a lineup where each cheese is a little wild, a little whimsical, and packed with flavor surprises. What started in 2006 as a modest operation focused on hand-selected 1- and 3-year Cheddars has become a creative playground where craft, curiosity, and imagination meet.

The first creature, The Fawn (just won silver at the World Cheese Awards 2025), was born from a collaboration with Wisconsin Master Cheesemaker Kerry Henning and brought to life visually by a teenage artist at home—Deer Creek’s daughter, Sophie. Her sketches set the tone: each cheese would be a character, each flavor a story. From there, kitchen experiments and long-time cheesemaking friendships gave rise to the rest of the series, including the silky, botanical Blue Jay, crafted with Master Cheesemaker Sid Cook of Carr Valley. Each release asks the same question: what could a classic Wisconsin cheese become if you let creativity run wild?

The Rattlesnake

A Cheddar that lives up to its name. This specialty cheese blends creamy, medium-aged Cheddar with premium gold tequila and dried habanero peppers. The tequila brings warm sweetness up front. Then, when the palate settles in, the heat strikes. The Rattlesnake earned gold for pepper-flavored cheese at the L.A. International Dairy Competition, and once tasted, it is easy to see why.

---

The Stag

Select wheels of The Fawn are set aside for deeper aging, transforming into The Stag. This traditional bandage-wrapped Cheddar shows off bold flavors with notes of toffee and butterscotch. As it continues to mature, it develops a delicate crystalline crunch that makes each bite fuller and more layered. The Stag has earned multiple first-place wins at the American Cheese Society and landed on Culture Magazine’s list of the 101 Best Cheeses of the Year.

---

The Swan

A quiet showstopper. The Swan pairs sheep’s milk Cheddar with a peppercorn-studded cow’s milk Cheddar, creating a striking visual and textural contrast. The result is rich, aromatic, and surprisingly graceful. The two cheeses meet in the middle the way its namesake birds do.

---

The Luna Moth

Here, Deer Creek takes handcrafted bandage-wrapped Cheddar and bathes it in elderflower liqueur. The infusion brings floral notes, a gentle sweetness, and hints of fruit that settle beautifully into the nutty base of the cheese. It is delicate and dreamy, the kind of cheese you savor slowly.

---

More Creatures to Discover

The Animal Series doesn’t stop with the fan favorites—there are ten more imaginative cheeses that keep the lineup fresh and surprising:

• The Imperial Buck (Just won gold at the World Cheese Awards 2025) – Richly nutty, robust extra-aged handmade Cheddar
• The Blue Jay – Juniper berry-infused quintuple crème blue cheese
• Snow Dancer – Holiday Cheddar with crystalline crunch, notes of hazelnut and toasted caramel, perfect fireside
• The Wild Boar – Wisconsin Monterey Jack marbled with black truffles
• The Carawaybou – Classic 1914-style Wisconsin Colby with caraway seeds
• The Robin – Old-fashioned Colby, firm and curdy with buttery, slightly salty finish
• The Indigo Bunting – Ultra-creamy sheep’s milk and cow’s cream blue cheese
• The Doe – Cheddar infused with Madagascar bourbon vanilla
• The Moon Rabbit – Sweet finish Cheddar bathed in Green Chartreuse, hints of cloves, citrus, rosemary, and thyme
• The Night Walker – Bandage-wrapped Cheddar soaked in J. Henry & Sons 5-year Wisconsin bourbon, rich with butterscotch and warm spice notes

Behind every Animal Series cheese is quality that starts on small family farms in Wisconsin’s Kettle Moraine region, where lush pastures shape every batch. The recipe stays simple—milk, salt, enzymes, cultures—while creativity shines through thoughtful additions like vanilla, habanero, juniper, black truffle, or a splash of liqueur.

These cheeses are made by people who care deeply about their craft. Years of experience, a passion for aging, and careful grading ensure every wheel hits the mark. Fans say they feel personal—and that makes sense, born from family, craft, and imagination.

The result is a lineup that tells stories, sparks curiosity, and keeps Wisconsin cheese lovers on their toes. Deer Creek set out to make great Cheddar—and ended up building a world of creatures and flavors that continues to charm cheese cases everywhere.

---