The Ultimate New Year’s Cheese Pairings

The Ultimate New Year’s Cheese Pairings

Ring in the New Year with bubbles, bites, and a little bit of indulgence—because what’s a celebration without cheese? From classic flutes to grown-up cider and inventive cocktails, there’s a perfect pairing waiting to elevate your midnight toast. Here’s how to match your favorite New Year’s sips with cheeses that make the night even more delicious.

Sparkling Wine: More Than Champagne

Think sparkling wine and cheese are just a Champagne-and-Brie cliché? Think again. You don’t have to splurge on the big-C label to feel festive. Crémant from France, Spain’s native cava, or Italy’s prosecco all bring that signature effervescence without emptying your wallet. Pair with rich, indulgent cheeses like triple crèmes for the ultimate holiday indulgence—or get adventurous with nutty aged gouda, tangy Camembert, or a creamy, bloomy-rind cheese.

• Kunik | Nettle Meadow Farm, NY – soft, creamy, and slightly tangy
• Mt. Tam | Cowgirl Creamery, CA – buttery and decadently rich
• Triple Crème Brie | Marin French, CA – smooth, indulgent, and ultra festive
• Bonus ideas: Brillat-Savarin, or St. André for extra decadence

---

Hard (or Zero-Proof) Cider: A Nostalgic Upgrade

Remember the childhood midnight toast with sparkling apple juice? Adulting has its perks: today’s sparkling ciders—both boozy and non-alcoholic—have depth, complexity, and plenty of personality. Sweet ciders play beautifully with aged grana-style wedges, while drier bottles shine alongside tangy chèvre or nutty sheep’s milk cheeses. For a twist, try pairing with aged gouda, blue-veined cheddar, or even a washed-rind cheese for a flavor punch.

• Sartori Bellavitano Gold | Sartori, WI – sweet, nutty, perfect with lightly sweet cider
• Bucheron | Montchevre, WI – creamy and tangy, balances dry cider
• Bonus ideas: Manchego, Aged Comté, or Fontina

---

Bitter-Based Cocktails: Bold Meets Creamy

Bitters are having a serious moment—once medicinal, now the unsung heroes of craft cocktails. A classic Old Fashioned pairs brilliantly with funky blue cheese, while a bitter twist on a Moscow Mule complements soft-ripened goat cheeses. Don’t be afraid to experiment: smoky whiskey, amaro, or aperitif cocktails all have a cheese soulmate, from pungent blues to earthy tommes.

• Bayley Hazen Blue | Jasper Hill Farms, VT – intense, creamy, with a salty bite
• Coupole | Vermont Creamery, VT – tangy and buttery, a perfect foil for herbal bitters
• Black & Blue | Firefly Farms, MD – bold, structured, and flavorful
• Bonus ideas: Roquefort, Bleu d’Auvergne, or Gorgonzola Dolce

---

Shrubs: Sweet, Sour, and Unexpected

Shrubs—sweetened fruit vinegars—are sneaky showstoppers. Mix them into cocktails or enjoy them straight for a tangy, fruity kick. Apple shrubs love nutty cheddar, citrus-based versions elevate fresh chèvre, and berry-forward blends are heavenly with creamy mascarpone. For more fun, pair with young gouda, camembert, or a semi-soft washed-rind cheese for layers of flavor.

• Fresh Goat Cheese | Laura Chenel, CA – bright, tangy, versatile
• Aged Cheddar | Grafton Village Cheese, VT – rich and nutty
• The Stag | Deer Creek Cheese, WI – complex, earthy, and slightly tangy
• Bonus ideas: Brie de Meaux, Tomme de Savoie, or Red Leicester

---

Fruit-Forward Sparklers: Keep the Bubbles, Add a Twist

Want to keep the traditional sparkling wine vibe but mix it up? Add fruit juice, bitters, or a garnish to create a festive, crowd-pleasing beverage. An apple-cinnamon kombucha sparkler brings cozy holiday vibes without overdoing the alcohol—perfect for midnight sipping in pajamas. Pair it with aged, mold-ripened goat cheeses, creamy blue-veined options, or tangy triple crèmes for a pairing that’s as fun as it is sophisticated.

• Humboldt Fog | Cypress Grove, CA – visually stunning with a creamy tang
• Bearded Lady | Prodigal Farm, NC – earthy, complex, and festive
• Bonus ideas: Valdeon, Saint Maure, or Garrotxa

---